The Mishewal Wappo Indians of Alexander Valley could be called Sonoma County's lost tribe.
They lost their land and their tribal status in 1959, along with 40 other tribes, under an act of Congress aimed at privatizing California's small Indian reservations.
While other tribes have regained their rights through lawsuits or congressional action, the Wappos struggled in vain for federal recognition.
Now they're close to achieving that goal. There's much at stake, including the potential for an Indian casino.
But the Wappos face some tough opposition. Sonoma County, Napa County and powerful politicians such as Sen. Dianne Feinstein are lined up against them.
The Wappos aren't backing down, said Scott Gabaldon, a 42-year-old contractor from Lake County who has been the tribe's chairman since 2007.
"My focus since day one has been getting my tribe restored, so we can reclaim the benefits we lost over 50 years ago," he said. "You're not going to get anything unless you fight for it."
The tribe has an unnamed partner who is financing its legal fight, and the investor would share any profits from future tribal enterprises.
The two counties are worried the Wappos will open a casino, in defiance of local land-use regulations.
"I'm very troubled that this recognition is directly linked to future gaming in the county," said Sonoma County Supervisor Mike McGuire, whose district includes Alexander Valley. "We're committed to protecting our local environment and agricultural heritage."
Gabaldon denied critics' contention that the Wappos' real interest is casino development. Still, he won't rule out a casino in the tribe's future. The tribe isn't making any plans until it gets recognition, he said.
"Right now, that's not my fight," he said.
Under the 1988 Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, federally recognized tribes can acquire land for casino operations. More than half of California's 109 tribes now have gaming.
But it's unclear where the Wappo tribe might locate.
The struggle is playing out in federal court in San Jose, where the Wappos sued U.S. Interior Secretary Ken Salazar nearly three years ago.
They say the federal government acted unlawfully when it disbanded the tribe in 1959. The former Alexander Valley Rancheria, their 54-acre reservation on a bend of the Russian River northeast of Healdsburg, now is in private hands.
Two years ago, Sonoma and Napa intervened in the Wappos' suit, arguing the tribe shouldn't be allowed to remove land from their jurisdictions without local approval.
They asked the federal court to dismiss the Wappos' claim, alleging the group waited too long to file their complaint. The counties also questioned the group's legitimacy, saying the Wappos don't qualify as a tribe under federal rules.
Gabaldon bristles at the claim the Wappos aren't a real tribe.
"I know that's not true," he said. "We were not lost. We never ceased to exist as a people."
But it's taken years for the tribe to reorganize and make its case for recognition.
The tribe now claims 357 enrolled members, all lineal descendants of 10 families who lived on the reservation in 1935.
The Wappos are asking the government to restore their tribal status, benefits and historic land rights.
They won a key victory earlier this month when U.S. District Court Judge Edward J. Davila denied Sonoma and Napa's efforts to dismiss their case.
The tribe now is in settlement talks with the Interior Department, but the counties still could appeal a judgment in the case.
The tribe's identity has emerged as a central issue in the court case. The counties argue there's no connection between today's Wappo leaders and the Indians who once lived on Alexander Valley Rancheria.
Attorneys for the tribe call that argument insulting, and accuse the two counties of "polluting the stream of history."
Both sides have called on historians to bolster their claims.
The counties hired Stephen Beckham, a history professor from Lewis & Clark College in Oregon, to examine the Wappos' past. In a 114-page report submitted to the court, he said Alexander Valley Rancheria wasn't a real Indian reservation and the Wappos never met the federal definition of a tribe.
"The courts cannot restore what never existed," Beckham concluded. "The rancheria was never a reservation and could not qualify as one under federal law.
"The Wappo never displayed any measure of tribal government of any kind at the rancheria. There was no recognition of a Wappo tribe by the United States, only the sometime residence of landless Indians of Wappo, Pomo and other tribes (and some non-Indians) on the rancheria."
Federal records show the Indians abandoned the land by 1951, Beckham said. The present-day Wappo tribe can't show any link to Indians who once lived on Alexander Valley Rancheria, he said.
UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy: